“It was you!” Michael shouts at Aldo. Michael backs away from Aldo as he slowly walks towards him.

Memories crash into Michael’s head. An older man drags Michael as a boy into a small, dark closet and shuts the door.

Aldo keeps walking toward Michael, and Lincoln wants to know what’s going on. Michael says that after their mother died, Michael was living with a foster family who would force him into the closet with the water heater as punishment. Michael recalls using objects inside the closet to escape, but the older man catches him and beats him to the ground.

Sara fights for air inside the water filled tub as Kellerman unpacks a bag containing a tarp and a saw to cut bone. Suddenly, there’s a knock at the door. Kellerman opens the door slightly and the manager pokes his head in. Other guests have been complaining about the volume of the television. Kellerman quiets the TV, but Sara splashing in the tub draws attention from the manager. Kellerman tells the manager that his daughter thinks bath time is play time.

Sara manages to snag the drain plug with her teeth, and pulls it from the drain.

Lincoln pushes Aldo back trying to straighten out the details. Michael is starting to unravel.

Michael remembers that Aldo was the one that saved him from the abusive foster father. A younger Aldo takes Michael’s hand from the closet. As they exit, young Michael looks back to see his foster father dead in a pool of blood.

Aldo tells Michael it’s going to be okay.

Kellerman hears the sound of water gurgling down the drain. He grabs his gun and quickly enters the bathroom. He sees the tub empty, and then Sara springs from behind a wall, forcing the scalding iron into Kellerman’s chest. Kellerman wails in pain, then collapses to the floor. Sara pushes the screen from the bathroom window on the second floor. She looks back and sees Kellerman grab his gun, then she leaps. She crashes down on the windshield of the car. Kellerman regains his footing and rushes to the window. When he looks out, Sara is gone.

Mahone makes his way to the shack where Michael met Coyote and his men. He looks around inside. He sees Coyote’s blood, and the vials of fishing reel oil. Mahone sees a trail of bloody foot prints, and follows them out of the shack.

Michael wants to know why it took Aldo so long to track Michael down as a child. Lincoln hangs back, letting the men work it out. Aldo tells Michael that he had to leave his children because The Company would have come for them first to get to Aldo when he turned on them. Aldo tells Michael about the tape recording of President Reynolds speaking with Steadman. Lincoln tells Michael they think Sara has it.

Kellerman holds a bag of ice to his chest and calls local hospitals looking for Sara. Agent Kim calls and asks for a status on Sara. Kellerman is forced to lie and tells Kim that she’s dead. Kim asks that Kellerman send him a photo of Sara’s body for confirmation. Kellerman tries to stall, but it won’t work.